Poker Lessons, Applied to Fantasy Football: Learning to Lose

February 24, 2013 1:50 pm3 commentsViews:

You’re going to lose.

It’s what happens after the losing that counts.

It’s a brutally important truth in any competition with luck baked into its innards, and it’s one you should accept, especially in fantasy football, and especially if you value your mental health.

You’re going to lose, no matter how many hours you pour into your research and analysis, no matter how much All-22 footage you watch, no matter how many instructive Twitter exchanges you have in a day or week or month. All that work could bring you a whole armful of fake football titles over the years, but along the way to collecting those trophies and cash deposits and satisfaction in knowing your arch nemeses have met their fantasy demise, you will lose.

You’ll lose in ways that rip your beating, bloody heart straight from your chest. You’ll be blown out, dismantled, humiliated. You’ll make lineup mistakes that haunt your Sunday night nightmares.

You’re going to lose. Let that wash over you.

The best, most obsessive poker players preach this ugly reality, making it a part of their mental training for the game they love. In “Poker Winners Are Different,” a tome by Alan Schoonmaker, an authority on poker psychology, readers are encouraged to embrace the inevitable losing that can’t be eliminated in a game sometimes determined by the dumbest of luck. Bad beats are part of the game, Schoonmaker writes. The sooner you accept that, the sooner you’ll improve. If you simply replace the word “poker” with “fantasy football,” Schoonmaker’s book reads like a psychological tip sheet for fantasy owners.

There’s a way to lose productively. Understand what you’ve done wrong, which players you’ve overvalued and undervalued, which waiver wire gems you should’ve snagged the previous Wednesday, and which weekly matchups were ripe for exploitation. To fail at this is to never improve.

Winners are different, Schoonmaker explains, because they don’t come unraveled when they find themselves on the losing end, and, most importantly, they resist the natural urge to retreat to a sort of competitive comfort zone, they deny their long-held illusions, and they embrace a model of almost robotic objectivity fueled by doing whatever it takes to win, to gain an edge, any edge.

They lose and they correct. It’s perhaps the most important lesson, at the poker table or on the make-believe gridiron.

Probably you think you play fantasy football this way: With cold efficiency, an unfeeling killer turned loose on your league of unsuspecting amateurs. Maybe you do, but I know from countless hours on the Twitter Machine that many owners – I dare say the vast majority — fight to keep their illusions about players and strategies firmly intact. They lose and they don’t correct. They blame luck. They blame fantasy writers. They blame the weather or a bad bounce or a bad call. Never themselves though – the guilt never falls on them, and no corrections are made. They stay the course, however flawed.

These fantasy owners never change. They draft a player because said player performed admirably for their fake football squad last year, if only for a few games. They roll out the same underperforming quarterback week after week, willfully ignoring better options on the waiver wire because this must be the week the signal caller breaks out. They draft quarterbacks early because that’s what they’ve always done. They always play a running back — even a middling one — in the flex spot because they’ve never done it any other way. They don’t use a tight end and wide receiver from the same team because they never have, and they’re not about to start. They turn down a juicy trade because they couldn’t bear to bid adieu to their hometown hero.

If you play this stupid little game casually, this approach works for you. And that’s OK. In fact, I envy your perspective. If, however, you play fantasy football for no other reason than to win money and the accolades that come with championship crowns, it’s high time to adopt Schoonmaker’s literary slap in the face.

“Losers respond primarily to their natural urges, especially their desire to be comfortable and to preserve their cherished illusions. Because winners are so intensely competitive, they resist their natural desires and do whatever it takes to maximize their edge. … They frequently ask themselves, ‘What is really happening? Why is it happening?’ … Instead of relying on first impressions and instincts, [winners] constantly seek new information and feed it back into their mental computers. They keep their minds open so they can process that information well.”

Closing your mind to contradictory information: I’ve been guilty of this mortal fake football sin, as have you. The easiest person to lie to, as you may know, is yourself. Fantasy footballers concoct and maintain these lies for self preservation – to embrace your own failings is painful, to lay the blame squarely on your own shoulders is devastating, and too much for many to absorb. This sounds melodramatic, I know, but take a look at your Twitter feed on a Sunday night and watch the string of angry, bitter, delusional tweeps looking for anyone to blame for their fantasy failings. These very owners, protecting their fragile egos from the blow of objectivity, will never change the way they approach the game because they don’t acknowledge their own missteps and deeply flawed strategies.

I’m not preaching from on high here. I’ve made these mistakes in a vain effort to make myself feel better about myself. Below is an excerpt from “Poker Winners Are Different,” one that exposes a hideous little reality about poker (and fantasy football): We don’t acknowledge our mistakes, and therefore don’t make necessary strategical changes because we are so hopelessly invested in the game. Our sense of self is tied to the performances of our fake football lineups, a decidedly unhealthy approach that must be avoided, for the sake of your emotional stability and your fantasy success.

“No matter how realistic you try to be, you will occasionally make these costly mistakes because luck’s short-term effects let you delude yourself about your abilities. You can take credit for your successes and blame luck, opponents’ mistakes, and other factors for your failures. You want to think well of yourself. The more your self-esteem depends on [fantasy football], the more likely you are to deny reality about yourself.”

Banish the chains of your well-constructed illusions, of the subjectivity that binds you, and approach your weekly decisions with objectivity, like the world’s most dominant poker players.

I lose, you lose, we all lose, even the best of us. In the wake of that losing, don’t lash out, don’t deflect the blame, and please don’t berate fantasy writers and rankers, most of whom toil for free, and out of love for the game.

It’s your team. It’s your fault. You’ve lost. Now go fix it.

This article is an excerpt from an upcoming eBook loosely titled, “Fantasy Football Winners Are Different,” scheduled for release in summer 2013. Look for more excerpts on Sports Jerks Network in the coming months.

  • http://twitter.com/FFMagicMan Micah James

    What is this losing you speak of? I am intrigued… :)

    One of the best things I did in 2012 was to track every team, player and weekly performance – from draft through playoffs (or not) and measured what moves I made. I could see which ones worked, which didn’t and how I can NOT make the same mistakes over again. It was an eye-opening exercise, one which I’d encourage others to consider. Plus it made even the losing worthwhile…

    • http://twitter.com/CDCarter13 C.D. Carter

      This is the feedback loop that so many owners ignore. How can you avoid making the same season-killing mistakes every year if you don’t know what you’re doing wrong? What you did with your 2012 players harkens back to how poker pros spend days evaluating their every decision during online practice sessions, determining where they went wrong and — most importantly — how they can avoid pitfalls. Thanks for reading, Micah.

  • Duncan Disorderly

    Great article that applies to so many things I’m doing in life right now, in addition to FFB. I was on a four-year run of success in my favorite fantasy league and I credited that success to my thought process, which really entailed analyzing things objectively and questioning if what I was reading really made logical sense. I drafted WR 1-2 in 09 when that was still a sin, I played Gronkowski in the flex at the start of last year. I tracked my roster vs. the league every week to see where I had strengths to exploit and weaknesses to cover. I won the league once, was in the finals two more times, and lost in the opening round in 2011 to the high scorer of the week by two points when DeMarco Murray broke his ankle and Tony Romo went off against me. Last year? Oy vey. My error was over thinking the draft and making some risky choices that proved to be disastrous. Yowza, that was a painful season but it was also the first year we went to keeper format. After starting 1-8, I swung three deals and now have eight of the first 43 picks next year, plus I’ve got Spiller in the 8th, Cobb in the 9th, and David Wilson in the 10th as keepers. Can’t wait for next year, and you can be sure I will not be repeating my self-inflicted wounds from last year.

SJN on Google+